Acknowledging Natural Punishment

Presented by Raff Donelson

Monday, 17 October, 2022 - 16:00

A natural punishment occurs when an agent commits a wrong, and then, as a result of this wrong, faces a significant harm that is not caused by anyone seeking retribution against the agent for their wrong. When the wrong in question is a crime, some legal systems explicitly acknowledge natural punishments and see these as reasons to lessen or forgo intentional punishment, while most legal systems decline to acknowledge natural punishment, or only do so implicitly. This article advances two arguments. First, all legal systems should be permitted to acknowledge natural punishment, contrary to the claims of some legal theorists. Second, and more boldly, the article contends that all legal systems have an affirmative duty to acknowledge natural punishment, not out of mercy but to respect the requirements of justice.
  • During the pandemic seminars will be held on-line; for the details of the Zoom meetings, please sign up for email notices at
  • Participants must read the paper prior to the seminar.
  • The paper will typically only be available on the Friday preceding the seminar.

  • Click here for the remainder of the seminar schedule for this semester.